Game Preserve

4.7 (48 reviews)

1551 E Stop 12 Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States, Indianapolis, IN

+1 317-881-4263

Visit Website View on Google Maps

Game Preserve

Reviews

Page 1 of 10
Showing 5 per page
Iron Coder
3 years ago
5

This store is awesome! The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The employees there learn your names too so you feel part of a community. The gamers here are polite friendly and willing to let new people into their social circle! I would highly suggest this store for gaming and ev... Read more

This store is awesome! The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The employees there learn your names too so you feel part of a community. The gamers here are polite friendly and willing to let new people into their social circle! I would highly suggest this store for gaming and even shopping! The prices are fair and their rewards system is great! Show less

Iron Coder
3 years ago
5

This store is awesome! The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The employees there learn your names too so you feel part of a community. The gamers here are polite friendly and willing to let new people into their social circle! I would highly suggest this store for gaming and ev... Read more

This store is awesome! The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The employees there learn your names too so you feel part of a community. The gamers here are polite friendly and willing to let new people into their social circle! I would highly suggest this store for gaming and even shopping! The prices are fair and their rewards system is great! Show less

Remington Crawford
2 years ago
5

Little gem of a place. Nice selection of board games and miniatures without the "unlit basement" feel that a lot of the older game shops had. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and helpful. I wish they hosted D&D style games (seems they're more focused on 40k and Magic) but still a nice l... Read more

Little gem of a place. Nice selection of board games and miniatures without the "unlit basement" feel that a lot of the older game shops had. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and helpful. I wish they hosted D&D style games (seems they're more focused on 40k and Magic) but still a nice little place. Show less

Remington Crawford
2 years ago
5

Little gem of a place. Nice selection of board games and miniatures without the "unlit basement" feel that a lot of the older game shops had. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and helpful. I wish they hosted D&D style games (seems they're more focused on 40k and Magic) but still a nice l... Read more

Little gem of a place. Nice selection of board games and miniatures without the "unlit basement" feel that a lot of the older game shops had. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and helpful. I wish they hosted D&D style games (seems they're more focused on 40k and Magic) but still a nice little place. Show less

Cody Jones
2 years ago
5

Great selection across the board, fair prices, and very friendly and knowledgeable staff. I'm a Dungeon Master who loves to paint miniatures for my homebrew sessions and I almost exclusively buy my supplies from the Game Preserve. If you're a gaming nerd in just about any capacity you'll find someth... Read more

Great selection across the board, fair prices, and very friendly and knowledgeable staff. I'm a Dungeon Master who loves to paint miniatures for my homebrew sessions and I almost exclusively buy my supplies from the Game Preserve. If you're a gaming nerd in just about any capacity you'll find something worthwhile here. 10/10 can't recommend enough. Show less

Cody Jones
2 years ago
5

Great selection across the board, fair prices, and very friendly and knowledgeable staff. I'm a Dungeon Master who loves to paint miniatures for my homebrew sessions and I almost exclusively buy my supplies from the Game Preserve. If you're a gaming nerd in just about any capacity you'll find someth... Read more

Great selection across the board, fair prices, and very friendly and knowledgeable staff. I'm a Dungeon Master who loves to paint miniatures for my homebrew sessions and I almost exclusively buy my supplies from the Game Preserve. If you're a gaming nerd in just about any capacity you'll find something worthwhile here. 10/10 can't recommend enough. Show less

Indiana JonesZ
1 year ago
5

Went there to look for some Magic cards, and they had quite a big collection. Many cards I was looking for. Reasonable priced as well. I’d suggest bringing a list of cards you need with you, because they keep their cards in alphabetical order, and you have to ask the employee to look for it. But the... Read more

Went there to look for some Magic cards, and they had quite a big collection. Many cards I was looking for. Reasonable priced as well. I’d suggest bringing a list of cards you need with you, because they keep their cards in alphabetical order, and you have to ask the employee to look for it. But the guy working there (Brad) was very friendly, and helped me look for certain cards. He also was very knowledgeable about the cards. Cool guy. Definitely will go back in the future. 👍 Show less

Indiana JonesZ
1 year ago
5

Went there to look for some Magic cards, and they had quite a big collection. Many cards I was looking for. Reasonable priced as well. I’d suggest bringing a list of cards you need with you, because they keep their cards in alphabetical order, and you have to ask the employee to look for it. But the... Read more

Went there to look for some Magic cards, and they had quite a big collection. Many cards I was looking for. Reasonable priced as well. I’d suggest bringing a list of cards you need with you, because they keep their cards in alphabetical order, and you have to ask the employee to look for it. But the guy working there (Brad) was very friendly, and helped me look for certain cards. He also was very knowledgeable about the cards. Cool guy. Definitely will go back in the future. 👍 Show less

Stephen Smith
2 years ago
5

This is a well organized game shop. They have almost all your tabletop gaming and miniature painting needs. With everything for every level rather you're just starting out or a seasoned player/dungeon master. Prices are very fair, and the staff is knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly.

Stephen Smith
2 years ago
5

This is a well organized game shop. They have almost all your tabletop gaming and miniature painting needs. With everything for every level rather you're just starting out or a seasoned player/dungeon master. Prices are very fair, and the staff is knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly.

Bob B.
2 months ago
5

Best game store in Indy hands down.

Bob B.
2 months ago
5

Best game store in Indy hands down.

Adam DeBard
1 year ago
2

They do have a nice, alphabetically organized inventory of Magic cards but won’t tell you if they have specific cards in stock over the phone, and ask you to bring in a list. I brought a list and the guy picking my cards seemed annoyed and barely said a word to me while I was there. Nice store, but ... Read more

They do have a nice, alphabetically organized inventory of Magic cards but won’t tell you if they have specific cards in stock over the phone, and ask you to bring in a list. I brought a list and the guy picking my cards seemed annoyed and barely said a word to me while I was there. Nice store, but the staff could be more accommodating. Show less

Adam DeBard
1 year ago
2

They do have a nice, alphabetically organized inventory of Magic cards but won’t tell you if they have specific cards in stock over the phone, and ask you to bring in a list. I brought a list and the guy picking my cards seemed annoyed and barely said a word to me while I was there. Nice store, but ... Read more

They do have a nice, alphabetically organized inventory of Magic cards but won’t tell you if they have specific cards in stock over the phone, and ask you to bring in a list. I brought a list and the guy picking my cards seemed annoyed and barely said a word to me while I was there. Nice store, but the staff could be more accommodating. Show less

CounterProductive Games
1 year ago
5

I'm from out of state and went there while visiting a friend. It is very comfortable, very well presented with nice wooden shelving, carpeting and a nice area in the back for gaming. The games were well displayed and the staff were very kind and helpful. Next time I visit, I'll definitely come again... Read more

I'm from out of state and went there while visiting a friend. It is very comfortable, very well presented with nice wooden shelving, carpeting and a nice area in the back for gaming. The games were well displayed and the staff were very kind and helpful. Next time I visit, I'll definitely come again. Show less

CounterProductive Games
1 year ago
5

I'm from out of state and went there while visiting a friend. It is very comfortable, very well presented with nice wooden shelving, carpeting and a nice area in the back for gaming. The games were well displayed and the staff were very kind and helpful. Next time I visit, I'll definitely come again... Read more

I'm from out of state and went there while visiting a friend. It is very comfortable, very well presented with nice wooden shelving, carpeting and a nice area in the back for gaming. The games were well displayed and the staff were very kind and helpful. Next time I visit, I'll definitely come again. Show less

Cosmic Queen
4 months ago
2

They only have one thing on their site and its a gift card, if they are gonna have a site, at least show the products available

Cosmic Queen
4 months ago
2

They only have one thing on their site and its a gift card, if they are gonna have a site, at least show the products available

Ben Peters
7 years ago
5

Great place to get my tabletop game needs and my miniature characters. Always a friendly staff and I have never had a bad experience there yet. Very knowledgeable about the items they carry and are always willing to help order something if they don't have it.

Ben Peters
7 years ago
5

Great place to get my tabletop game needs and my miniature characters. Always a friendly staff and I have never had a bad experience there yet. Very knowledgeable about the items they carry and are always willing to help order something if they don't have it.

Tommy TwoBeards
3 months ago
5

Really good selection of Warhammer 40k stuff. This location is top notch

Tommy TwoBeards
3 months ago
5

Really good selection of Warhammer 40k stuff. This location is top notch

Gregg Hamilton
6 months ago
4

My second favorite gaming store! Slightly higher prices here as compared to most. Wish they would bring back Reaper brand miniatures

Gregg Hamilton
6 months ago
4

My second favorite gaming store! Slightly higher prices here as compared to most. Wish they would bring back Reaper brand miniatures

Xavier Harbaugh
8 months ago
1

They have magic singles and card games but multiple staff members are downright unpleasant and harm the business. The guy with glasses, long curly brown hair, and always wears a mask is the worst of the bunch on that. I've seen him be purposely rude to multiple people over the times I've been in th... Read more

They have magic singles and card games but multiple staff members are downright unpleasant and harm the business. The guy with glasses, long curly brown hair, and always wears a mask is the worst of the bunch on that. I've seen him be purposely rude to multiple people over the times I've been in there and have had him act the same way to myself when i asked about a magic single on display. Wouldn't want to imagine the ammount of people that have gotten turned around as customers from his behavior alone. Despite the business having good stock and a large store, it makes ya wanna go somewhere else when you see that type of thing 50% of the time you go in. They got less stock but I'd recommend the gamers guild or the shop just up north by wallmart that specializes in yugioh cards to get your mtg stuff. Both will let you order things to the store and have better staff. Either that or just order online. Show less

Xavier Harbaugh
8 months ago
1

They have magic singles and card games but multiple staff members are downright unpleasant and harm the business. The guy with glasses, long curly brown hair, and always wears a mask is the worst of the bunch on that. I've seen him be purposely rude to multiple people over the times I've been in th... Read more

They have magic singles and card games but multiple staff members are downright unpleasant and harm the business. The guy with glasses, long curly brown hair, and always wears a mask is the worst of the bunch on that. I've seen him be purposely rude to multiple people over the times I've been in there and have had him act the same way to myself when i asked about a magic single on display. Wouldn't want to imagine the ammount of people that have gotten turned around as customers from his behavior alone. Despite the business having good stock and a large store, it makes ya wanna go somewhere else when you see that type of thing 50% of the time you go in. They got less stock but I'd recommend the gamers guild or the shop just up north by wallmart that specializes in yugioh cards to get your mtg stuff. Both will let you order things to the store and have better staff. Either that or just order online. Show less

Stephani Payne
7 months ago
5

Love going here! Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly!!! There prices are not bad either I'm a big D&D gamer and this is my to go to spot!!

Stephani Payne
7 months ago
5

Love going here! Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly!!! There prices are not bad either I'm a big D&D gamer and this is my to go to spot!!

fox lildeath
7 months ago
4

It's a grate store they have most of what you could look for they have magic cards they sell singles and they have warhamer and other minis along with paint and such they also have other bordgames and the staf is frankly realy nice all in all a really good place

fox lildeath
7 months ago
4

It's a grate store they have most of what you could look for they have magic cards they sell singles and they have warhamer and other minis along with paint and such they also have other bordgames and the staf is frankly realy nice all in all a really good place

Mark Hughey
6 months ago
5

If not for Hitherto, this would absolutely be our gaming store of choice. Nice big, well maintained layout, good categorizing of games, friendly staff. Well worth the visit.

Mark Hughey
6 months ago
5

If not for Hitherto, this would absolutely be our gaming store of choice. Nice big, well maintained layout, good categorizing of games, friendly staff. Well worth the visit.

Kyle Matsumura
2 months ago
5

Great selection, friendly and knowledgeable staff! What more could you ask for? They also take orders and reservations for games.

Kyle Matsumura
2 months ago
5

Great selection, friendly and knowledgeable staff! What more could you ask for? They also take orders and reservations for games.

Dustin Savage
3 months ago
5

The best in board games and trading card games. There's also space to set up and play games. I believe there are certain days for tabletop games though

Dustin Savage
3 months ago
5

The best in board games and trading card games. There's also space to set up and play games. I believe there are certain days for tabletop games though

Mike Stierwalt
6 years ago
5

I'm not a gamer but if I was I'd shop here. Came in to get some Christmas gifts and was blown away at the selection of games. Super friendly staff.

Mike Stierwalt
6 years ago
5

I'm not a gamer but if I was I'd shop here. Came in to get some Christmas gifts and was blown away at the selection of games. Super friendly staff.

Dan Wolff
1 year ago
5

This game store easily clears all others in Indy (perhaps excluding its own second location). Great selection and knowledgeable staff, their points rewards system is the only one that's actually worth your while! Great place to play warhammer and magic the gathering on tournament nights. The redesig... Read more

This game store easily clears all others in Indy (perhaps excluding its own second location). Great selection and knowledgeable staff, their points rewards system is the only one that's actually worth your while! Great place to play warhammer and magic the gathering on tournament nights. The redesign really brought new life, I love the fantastical interior. Show less

Dan Wolff
1 year ago
5

This game store easily clears all others in Indy (perhaps excluding its own second location). Great selection and knowledgeable staff, their points rewards system is the only one that's actually worth your while! Great place to play warhammer and magic the gathering on tournament nights. The redesig... Read more

This game store easily clears all others in Indy (perhaps excluding its own second location). Great selection and knowledgeable staff, their points rewards system is the only one that's actually worth your while! Great place to play warhammer and magic the gathering on tournament nights. The redesign really brought new life, I love the fantastical interior. Show less

Jonathan Powley
3 years ago
5

You might be thinking to yourself, "I know it smell crazy in there." And depending on the day and density of gamers present, you might be right. But that's part of the atmosphere that comes with the territory, and when it comes to tabletop gaming, CCGs, miniatures, and related hobbyist paraphernalia... Read more

You might be thinking to yourself, "I know it smell crazy in there." And depending on the day and density of gamers present, you might be right. But that's part of the atmosphere that comes with the territory, and when it comes to tabletop gaming, CCGs, miniatures, and related hobbyist paraphernalia, the Game Preserve is the absolute one-stop shop. One can frequently find dudes running TTRPG campaigns or Magic: The Gathering card tournaments in the large connected game room, which is a blessing for avid gamers of all ages looking to satisfy that anytime itch whenever GenCon isn't currently happening in Indy. Go buy some games for your home there, and you'll almost certainly be able to find someone who can explain it to you in great detail. Show less

Jonathan Powley
3 years ago
5

You might be thinking to yourself, "I know it smell crazy in there." And depending on the day and density of gamers present, you might be right. But that's part of the atmosphere that comes with the territory, and when it comes to tabletop gaming, CCGs, miniatures, and related hobbyist paraphernalia... Read more

You might be thinking to yourself, "I know it smell crazy in there." And depending on the day and density of gamers present, you might be right. But that's part of the atmosphere that comes with the territory, and when it comes to tabletop gaming, CCGs, miniatures, and related hobbyist paraphernalia, the Game Preserve is the absolute one-stop shop. One can frequently find dudes running TTRPG campaigns or Magic: The Gathering card tournaments in the large connected game room, which is a blessing for avid gamers of all ages looking to satisfy that anytime itch whenever GenCon isn't currently happening in Indy. Go buy some games for your home there, and you'll almost certainly be able to find someone who can explain it to you in great detail. Show less

Timothy P
5 months ago
5

Always loved The Game Preserve since I was 12. Now I'm in my mid 40s and still love patronizing this business. My daughter and I came in on a Friday night and the place was packed and everyone was having fun. Thanks for decades of great gaming!

Timothy P
5 months ago
5

Always loved The Game Preserve since I was 12. Now I'm in my mid 40s and still love patronizing this business. My daughter and I came in on a Friday night and the place was packed and everyone was having fun. Thanks for decades of great gaming!

Carla Knapp
6 years ago
5

In my unscientific estimate, there's probably a zillion different ways to have fun in this store. There's just so many games! No matter what genre of tabletop gaming you're into, whether you're a casual player or dedicated gamer, Game Preserve will definitely have something for you. Beginning in th... Read more

In my unscientific estimate, there's probably a zillion different ways to have fun in this store. There's just so many games! No matter what genre of tabletop gaming you're into, whether you're a casual player or dedicated gamer, Game Preserve will definitely have something for you. Beginning in the front of the store, you'll find the familiar family favorites. As you work your way in, you'll discover rows of dice, cards and what seems like every board game under the sun. If you have a favorite movie or TV show, they have games for that. Like historic or sci-fi themes? They have those games. Party games? Yep. Popular new releases? Got those. Miniature games? Yes, plus all the paints and brushes to customize your set. Staff is always super friendly and helpful when you're looking for something specific or trying to choose between their many titles. I've bought several gifts there plus several games for myself, all have been a huge hit. In the evenings, they open up their huge side room for games (I often see people playing Magic the Gathering and I know there’s open game nights too). Plus there's a rewards program for repeat customers. I'll definitely be back! Show less

Carla Knapp
6 years ago
5

In my unscientific estimate, there's probably a zillion different ways to have fun in this store. There's just so many games! No matter what genre of tabletop gaming you're into, whether you're a casual player or dedicated gamer, Game Preserve will definitely have something for you. Beginning in th... Read more

In my unscientific estimate, there's probably a zillion different ways to have fun in this store. There's just so many games! No matter what genre of tabletop gaming you're into, whether you're a casual player or dedicated gamer, Game Preserve will definitely have something for you. Beginning in the front of the store, you'll find the familiar family favorites. As you work your way in, you'll discover rows of dice, cards and what seems like every board game under the sun. If you have a favorite movie or TV show, they have games for that. Like historic or sci-fi themes? They have those games. Party games? Yep. Popular new releases? Got those. Miniature games? Yes, plus all the paints and brushes to customize your set. Staff is always super friendly and helpful when you're looking for something specific or trying to choose between their many titles. I've bought several gifts there plus several games for myself, all have been a huge hit. In the evenings, they open up their huge side room for games (I often see people playing Magic the Gathering and I know there’s open game nights too). Plus there's a rewards program for repeat customers. I'll definitely be back! Show less

Natalia Cruz
7 months ago
5

There are a number of board game shops in indy and this is one of the nicer ones. There was a large selection of games from cards to board games. I liked all the dragons they had in the store. It really tied in to the whole old timey vibes to the store. Will say location can be easy to miss if comin... Read more

There are a number of board game shops in indy and this is one of the nicer ones. There was a large selection of games from cards to board games. I liked all the dragons they had in the store. It really tied in to the whole old timey vibes to the store. Will say location can be easy to miss if coming from the main road. Show less

Natalia Cruz
7 months ago
5

There are a number of board game shops in indy and this is one of the nicer ones. There was a large selection of games from cards to board games. I liked all the dragons they had in the store. It really tied in to the whole old timey vibes to the store. Will say location can be easy to miss if comin... Read more

There are a number of board game shops in indy and this is one of the nicer ones. There was a large selection of games from cards to board games. I liked all the dragons they had in the store. It really tied in to the whole old timey vibes to the store. Will say location can be easy to miss if coming from the main road. Show less

Jeremy Cowin
2 months ago
5

Game Preserve is always one of our go-to place for board games. They have an excellent selection, and it’s rare that we’re looking for something they don’t have. While we usually don’t play games there, it’s great that they even have a dedicated game room for anyone who wants that experience. Today... Read more

Game Preserve is always one of our go-to place for board games. They have an excellent selection, and it’s rare that we’re looking for something they don’t have. While we usually don’t play games there, it’s great that they even have a dedicated game room for anyone who wants that experience. Today we stopped in to pick up Lost Ruins of Arnak, and of course they had it — along with the expansions. Knowledgeable staff, great inventory, and a true passion for board games. If you enjoy tabletop gaming at any level, this place is a must-visit. Show less

Jeremy Cowin
2 months ago
5

Game Preserve is always one of our go-to place for board games. They have an excellent selection, and it’s rare that we’re looking for something they don’t have. While we usually don’t play games there, it’s great that they even have a dedicated game room for anyone who wants that experience. Today... Read more

Game Preserve is always one of our go-to place for board games. They have an excellent selection, and it’s rare that we’re looking for something they don’t have. While we usually don’t play games there, it’s great that they even have a dedicated game room for anyone who wants that experience. Today we stopped in to pick up Lost Ruins of Arnak, and of course they had it — along with the expansions. Knowledgeable staff, great inventory, and a true passion for board games. If you enjoy tabletop gaming at any level, this place is a must-visit. Show less

Page 1 of 10
Opening Hours

Monday: 10 AM to 9 PM Tuesday: 10 AM to 9 PM Wednesday: 10 AM to 9 PM Thursday: 10 AM to 9 PM Friday: 10 AM to 9 PM Saturday: 10 AM to 9 PM Sunday: 11 AM to 6 PM