Game Time
8244 Center Run Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States, Indianapolis, IN
Photos
Reviews
Daniel Friedman
4 years agoThis place is terrible. I came in looking to sell my Pokémon cards. When I gave them my cards they took them to the back where I believe they swapped out some of my almost-mint condition cards for some bad, poorly handled cards. When they came back, they picked out about 15 cards and offered $64 for... Read more
This place is terrible. I came in looking to sell my Pokémon cards. When I gave them my cards they took them to the back where I believe they swapped out some of my almost-mint condition cards for some bad, poorly handled cards. When they came back, they picked out about 15 cards and offered $64 for all of them which is greatly undervalued. I know these places buy low sell high but some of those cards were worth about $20 each. Also, when they came back and gave the cards back to me, my mint condition heracross (shown in pictures) looked like some 4-year-old messed with them. When I brought this up, they claimed none of the cards have been tampered with and refused to do anything about it. DO NOT GO HERE. Show less
Daniel Friedman
4 years agoThis place is terrible. I came in looking to sell my Pokémon cards. When I gave them my cards they took them to the back where I believe they swapped out some of my almost-mint condition cards for some bad, poorly handled cards. When they came back, they picked out about 15 cards and offered $64 for... Read more
This place is terrible. I came in looking to sell my Pokémon cards. When I gave them my cards they took them to the back where I believe they swapped out some of my almost-mint condition cards for some bad, poorly handled cards. When they came back, they picked out about 15 cards and offered $64 for all of them which is greatly undervalued. I know these places buy low sell high but some of those cards were worth about $20 each. Also, when they came back and gave the cards back to me, my mint condition heracross (shown in pictures) looked like some 4-year-old messed with them. When I brought this up, they claimed none of the cards have been tampered with and refused to do anything about it. DO NOT GO HERE. Show less
Gurinder Khera
4 months agoI come to this store often it is a great shop with great people and a great selection of cards would highly recommend
Gurinder Khera
4 months agoI come to this store often it is a great shop with great people and a great selection of cards would highly recommend
Shookaka
11 months agoShop looked amazing, I personally was looking at Lorcana singles but they didn't really have much in that department (they had a lot of sealed product). Shop has a ton of MTG for those interested.
Shookaka
11 months agoShop looked amazing, I personally was looking at Lorcana singles but they didn't really have much in that department (they had a lot of sealed product). Shop has a ton of MTG for those interested.
Zayn Typhon
2 months agoGreat atmosphere with a large product selection not carried by other local retailers, including older products otherwise hard to find
Zayn Typhon
2 months agoGreat atmosphere with a large product selection not carried by other local retailers, including older products otherwise hard to find
K Ables Ripke
9 months agoGreat Store Nice Staff Helped Us Big Selection Of JP Pokemon Cards And Packs
K Ables Ripke
9 months agoGreat Store Nice Staff Helped Us Big Selection Of JP Pokemon Cards And Packs
Elijah Cohan
3 months agoGreat staff and great community, vary chill to play or go draft been going for a while and always love it❤️ (I play mtg for clarification)
Elijah Cohan
3 months agoGreat staff and great community, vary chill to play or go draft been going for a while and always love it❤️ (I play mtg for clarification)
Adam Burk
12 months agoMy buddy told me this store was good. We went in picked out some magic singles. Drove 30 minutes because he loves this shop, and asked to play magic. YOU CANT PLAY GAMES IN THEIR GAME STORE. What kind of games store can't you play games in? Sounds like they lost touch of what brings people into thes... Read more
My buddy told me this store was good. We went in picked out some magic singles. Drove 30 minutes because he loves this shop, and asked to play magic. YOU CANT PLAY GAMES IN THEIR GAME STORE. What kind of games store can't you play games in? Sounds like they lost touch of what brings people into these kinds of stores. You come for the experience and , convenience of snacks and drinks, and to spend time with friends. Show less
Adam Burk
12 months agoMy buddy told me this store was good. We went in picked out some magic singles. Drove 30 minutes because he loves this shop, and asked to play magic. YOU CANT PLAY GAMES IN THEIR GAME STORE. What kind of games store can't you play games in? Sounds like they lost touch of what brings people into thes... Read more
My buddy told me this store was good. We went in picked out some magic singles. Drove 30 minutes because he loves this shop, and asked to play magic. YOU CANT PLAY GAMES IN THEIR GAME STORE. What kind of games store can't you play games in? Sounds like they lost touch of what brings people into these kinds of stores. You come for the experience and , convenience of snacks and drinks, and to spend time with friends. Show less
Andy Huynh
4 years agoI didn’t have a problem here. Thought some of the cards were overpriced, but that’s the name of the game I guess. The workers were cool and I picked up some cool cards. Will likely come back Update: have been going to this store for months and it’s become my favorite TCG store in the area. Great s... Read more
I didn’t have a problem here. Thought some of the cards were overpriced, but that’s the name of the game I guess. The workers were cool and I picked up some cool cards. Will likely come back Update: have been going to this store for months and it’s become my favorite TCG store in the area. Great singles selection and really cool workers. Still think some of the boxes are overpriced but eh, that’s alright. Show less
Andy Huynh
4 years agoI didn’t have a problem here. Thought some of the cards were overpriced, but that’s the name of the game I guess. The workers were cool and I picked up some cool cards. Will likely come back Update: have been going to this store for months and it’s become my favorite TCG store in the area. Great s... Read more
I didn’t have a problem here. Thought some of the cards were overpriced, but that’s the name of the game I guess. The workers were cool and I picked up some cool cards. Will likely come back Update: have been going to this store for months and it’s become my favorite TCG store in the area. Great singles selection and really cool workers. Still think some of the boxes are overpriced but eh, that’s alright. Show less
Scott Christiana
2 months agoGreat shop, when I was an over the road trucker this was my go to LGS out of all the ones I saw across the country
Scott Christiana
2 months agoGreat shop, when I was an over the road trucker this was my go to LGS out of all the ones I saw across the country
Jacob Strain
4 months agoGreat folks working here. They were able to grab some cards for me in addition to the order I placed online. I respect their attentiveness to customers!
Jacob Strain
4 months agoGreat folks working here. They were able to grab some cards for me in addition to the order I placed online. I respect their attentiveness to customers!
Brian McNamee
9 months agoI have been here multiple times. Most of my experiences have been positive. One of the best positives that game time offers is their employees. Sophie was extremely kind and helpful, and then remembered me from a previous visit that I liked a certain Pokémon character and had pulled cards aside for... Read more
I have been here multiple times. Most of my experiences have been positive. One of the best positives that game time offers is their employees. Sophie was extremely kind and helpful, and then remembered me from a previous visit that I liked a certain Pokémon character and had pulled cards aside for me in the event that I came back. I’ve worked with Jeremy who I believe might be the owner on more than one occasion, and he has been nothing but friendly. I was able to show him a new function on how to look up Japanese Pokémon cards, and he was receptive and kind to the information. Though we couldn’t come to a deal today he was open and transparent about his negotiation, and I will be back in the future to look at their selection of cards. Show less
Brian McNamee
9 months agoI have been here multiple times. Most of my experiences have been positive. One of the best positives that game time offers is their employees. Sophie was extremely kind and helpful, and then remembered me from a previous visit that I liked a certain Pokémon character and had pulled cards aside for... Read more
I have been here multiple times. Most of my experiences have been positive. One of the best positives that game time offers is their employees. Sophie was extremely kind and helpful, and then remembered me from a previous visit that I liked a certain Pokémon character and had pulled cards aside for me in the event that I came back. I’ve worked with Jeremy who I believe might be the owner on more than one occasion, and he has been nothing but friendly. I was able to show him a new function on how to look up Japanese Pokémon cards, and he was receptive and kind to the information. Though we couldn’t come to a deal today he was open and transparent about his negotiation, and I will be back in the future to look at their selection of cards. Show less
Kaylee King
3 months agoI bought maybe 4-5 packs all different sets , not only were the pokemon packs all wonky but it seemed weirdly messed with and my results from those packs came out with cards not from that set at all
Kaylee King
3 months agoI bought maybe 4-5 packs all different sets , not only were the pokemon packs all wonky but it seemed weirdly messed with and my results from those packs came out with cards not from that set at all
Rosa New
4 years agoFirst time at this place. I bought a bunch of their $10 bulk boxes of commons/uncommons. I was curious what the breakdown of cards inside was like so I counted: Average around 400-450 cards, no basic mana, a little non-basic land. ~100 unique cards per bulk pack (so still decent number of duplicate... Read more
First time at this place. I bought a bunch of their $10 bulk boxes of commons/uncommons. I was curious what the breakdown of cards inside was like so I counted: Average around 400-450 cards, no basic mana, a little non-basic land. ~100 unique cards per bulk pack (so still decent number of duplicates BUT the highest # of dups for one card was 12 with an average of 3-4 dups per card... not bad at all imo. ~13% of the packs were uncommons. They're all separated by set, which is nice if you're trying to fill out a collection. I've had some bad experiences in the past with grab boxes having like... 50 duplicates of multiple cards. Not the case with Game Time's boxes. For 10 bucks, these grab boxes are really well-made. Its obvious going through the cards that they had been sorted and an attempt was made to be fair and equal (no chunks of all blue or white cards.) Very evenly distributed across the colors. I think these boxes are EXCELLENT for younger players who need a good variety of cards without breaking the bank. Its not like the deal of the century or anything, considering you're getting mostly commons but the variety and even distribution of cards across all colors makes me believe the guys that packed this box were not just using them as a worthless dump of commons. They actually put time and effort into making these boxes worth every dollar. (See photos for even distribution of colors. The stacks at the bottom of the the photos are the unique cards with the larger stacks behind them are the duplicates.) The employees seemed friendly and knowledgeable too. Show less
Rosa New
4 years agoFirst time at this place. I bought a bunch of their $10 bulk boxes of commons/uncommons. I was curious what the breakdown of cards inside was like so I counted: Average around 400-450 cards, no basic mana, a little non-basic land. ~100 unique cards per bulk pack (so still decent number of duplicate... Read more
First time at this place. I bought a bunch of their $10 bulk boxes of commons/uncommons. I was curious what the breakdown of cards inside was like so I counted: Average around 400-450 cards, no basic mana, a little non-basic land. ~100 unique cards per bulk pack (so still decent number of duplicates BUT the highest # of dups for one card was 12 with an average of 3-4 dups per card... not bad at all imo. ~13% of the packs were uncommons. They're all separated by set, which is nice if you're trying to fill out a collection. I've had some bad experiences in the past with grab boxes having like... 50 duplicates of multiple cards. Not the case with Game Time's boxes. For 10 bucks, these grab boxes are really well-made. Its obvious going through the cards that they had been sorted and an attempt was made to be fair and equal (no chunks of all blue or white cards.) Very evenly distributed across the colors. I think these boxes are EXCELLENT for younger players who need a good variety of cards without breaking the bank. Its not like the deal of the century or anything, considering you're getting mostly commons but the variety and even distribution of cards across all colors makes me believe the guys that packed this box were not just using them as a worthless dump of commons. They actually put time and effort into making these boxes worth every dollar. (See photos for even distribution of colors. The stacks at the bottom of the the photos are the unique cards with the larger stacks behind them are the duplicates.) The employees seemed friendly and knowledgeable too. Show less
izzy marlow
11 months agoI was buying pokémon cards for my bf. I have no idea anything about pokémon. however, the gentlemen here were SO kind! I LOVED my experience. they helped me figure out what i was looking for with no judgement. very satisfied. 10/10 will be coming again.
izzy marlow
11 months agoI was buying pokémon cards for my bf. I have no idea anything about pokémon. however, the gentlemen here were SO kind! I LOVED my experience. they helped me figure out what i was looking for with no judgement. very satisfied. 10/10 will be coming again.
Dennis Brumfield
2 months agoGreat place. Always quick about getting card lists filled fast! I go for pokemon cards and always happy with what they have.
Dennis Brumfield
2 months agoGreat place. Always quick about getting card lists filled fast! I go for pokemon cards and always happy with what they have.
Tiffany Johns
6 months agoToo many problems to tell I just you leave you this … The C on the cards meaning the card has a condition sold me a slab that has a crack in it and they cover it with a sticker bought a few packs of cards and went back to buy more and they walk away from me and my son people there are very stuck up ... Read more
Too many problems to tell I just you leave you this … The C on the cards meaning the card has a condition sold me a slab that has a crack in it and they cover it with a sticker bought a few packs of cards and went back to buy more and they walk away from me and my son people there are very stuck up and will not be going back there Show less
Tiffany Johns
6 months agoToo many problems to tell I just you leave you this … The C on the cards meaning the card has a condition sold me a slab that has a crack in it and they cover it with a sticker bought a few packs of cards and went back to buy more and they walk away from me and my son people there are very stuck up ... Read more
Too many problems to tell I just you leave you this … The C on the cards meaning the card has a condition sold me a slab that has a crack in it and they cover it with a sticker bought a few packs of cards and went back to buy more and they walk away from me and my son people there are very stuck up and will not be going back there Show less
kenzie ravenwood
3 months agoExactly what I want in customer service! I came in with little knowledge just wanting to get back into Pokémon cards. The employee who helped made me feel comfortable in picking the right packs. I’ll definitely be back
kenzie ravenwood
3 months agoExactly what I want in customer service! I came in with little knowledge just wanting to get back into Pokémon cards. The employee who helped made me feel comfortable in picking the right packs. I’ll definitely be back
Ken K
5 months agoThey completely ripped me off before and gave me 15% of what my collection was worth as store credit. And the cards they sell are extremely overpriced. Some are literally double the current market price. Go anywhere else and you will get a better deal buying or selling cards.
Ken K
5 months agoThey completely ripped me off before and gave me 15% of what my collection was worth as store credit. And the cards they sell are extremely overpriced. Some are literally double the current market price. Go anywhere else and you will get a better deal buying or selling cards.
Liam Robinson
3 months agoA fun shop and one of the best places to get magic cards in the city. They have a large selection making a good chance they have that 20 cent uncommon you have been hunting.
Liam Robinson
3 months agoA fun shop and one of the best places to get magic cards in the city. They have a large selection making a good chance they have that 20 cent uncommon you have been hunting.
Brandon Reddish
6 months agoI wish I had something nice to say about this place, but unfortunately the customer service on two completely separate times by two separate employees have been horrible. If you question the value offered of selling cards, they will not hesitate to demean you and explain how a customer should “under... Read more
I wish I had something nice to say about this place, but unfortunately the customer service on two completely separate times by two separate employees have been horrible. If you question the value offered of selling cards, they will not hesitate to demean you and explain how a customer should “understand basic economics” before trying to sell cards. Yikes, right? If they tell you something specific on the phone, do not expect them to honor it when you drive 30 minutes to make a transaction. Apparently 25 minutes before closing is “too close to closing” to help a customer. There are several other great trading card stores in the area and I highly recommend any other one besides this one. Show less
Brandon Reddish
6 months agoI wish I had something nice to say about this place, but unfortunately the customer service on two completely separate times by two separate employees have been horrible. If you question the value offered of selling cards, they will not hesitate to demean you and explain how a customer should “under... Read more
I wish I had something nice to say about this place, but unfortunately the customer service on two completely separate times by two separate employees have been horrible. If you question the value offered of selling cards, they will not hesitate to demean you and explain how a customer should “understand basic economics” before trying to sell cards. Yikes, right? If they tell you something specific on the phone, do not expect them to honor it when you drive 30 minutes to make a transaction. Apparently 25 minutes before closing is “too close to closing” to help a customer. There are several other great trading card stores in the area and I highly recommend any other one besides this one. Show less
Jeff U
2 months agoThey usually have the MTG cards I want, but they come at a price higher than most other LGSs with a trade in price lower than most others. I understand they say the price they offer fluctuates, but consistently getting less than 50% market value hurts my soul.
Jeff U
2 months agoThey usually have the MTG cards I want, but they come at a price higher than most other LGSs with a trade in price lower than most others. I understand they say the price they offer fluctuates, but consistently getting less than 50% market value hurts my soul.
Katelyn Reynolds
5 months agoIf you are a serious collector I do not recommend trading and selling cards here. They do not offer a reasonable value. Do not waste your time. I was told I had a nice collection and asked what I was looking for it. I mentioned I had not comped it in a minute. I was told that makes sense because a ... Read more
If you are a serious collector I do not recommend trading and selling cards here. They do not offer a reasonable value. Do not waste your time. I was told I had a nice collection and asked what I was looking for it. I mentioned I had not comped it in a minute. I was told that makes sense because a lot of it rose in value. He then proceeded to offer me 1k less than another shop. There isn’t a clearer demonstration of lacking integrity. Show less
Katelyn Reynolds
5 months agoIf you are a serious collector I do not recommend trading and selling cards here. They do not offer a reasonable value. Do not waste your time. I was told I had a nice collection and asked what I was looking for it. I mentioned I had not comped it in a minute. I was told that makes sense because a ... Read more
If you are a serious collector I do not recommend trading and selling cards here. They do not offer a reasonable value. Do not waste your time. I was told I had a nice collection and asked what I was looking for it. I mentioned I had not comped it in a minute. I was told that makes sense because a lot of it rose in value. He then proceeded to offer me 1k less than another shop. There isn’t a clearer demonstration of lacking integrity. Show less
Holden Francis
4 months agoCalled over the phone to ask about pricing for cards. On the cards I had, I was told 60-70% in store credit. Not to my surprise, I also put in a list to get done at the same time and my oh my they’re the same price. The original price of the cards? $500 all together. I got offered $170, the exact pr... Read more
Called over the phone to ask about pricing for cards. On the cards I had, I was told 60-70% in store credit. Not to my surprise, I also put in a list to get done at the same time and my oh my they’re the same price. The original price of the cards? $500 all together. I got offered $170, the exact price for my list. In short, I came in, was lied to about percentage, then they didn’t do their job and tried to change how their prices worked in person. Even the man behind the counter looked shocked when I told him the original value. Why? Because someone was just trying to rush and go play magic. Hey. I get it. But I’m selling you cards then using that money and maybe even more to put back into the store and I was sold 34% in store credit when I was told 60-70. I would’ve even settled for half. That’s pathetic and really shouldn’t be happening to someone who’s been shopping there for years. I hate writing this but I haven’t been treated this poorly in a very long time. I hope they can fix this issue and be more clear on their pricing because the reality is you’re not getting what you’re cards are worth and you won’t get what they will tell you they’re worth. Wish it could’ve went different. Also just noticing that my cards aren’t even in a different order from when they started XD DONT SHOP HERE Show less
Holden Francis
4 months agoCalled over the phone to ask about pricing for cards. On the cards I had, I was told 60-70% in store credit. Not to my surprise, I also put in a list to get done at the same time and my oh my they’re the same price. The original price of the cards? $500 all together. I got offered $170, the exact pr... Read more
Called over the phone to ask about pricing for cards. On the cards I had, I was told 60-70% in store credit. Not to my surprise, I also put in a list to get done at the same time and my oh my they’re the same price. The original price of the cards? $500 all together. I got offered $170, the exact price for my list. In short, I came in, was lied to about percentage, then they didn’t do their job and tried to change how their prices worked in person. Even the man behind the counter looked shocked when I told him the original value. Why? Because someone was just trying to rush and go play magic. Hey. I get it. But I’m selling you cards then using that money and maybe even more to put back into the store and I was sold 34% in store credit when I was told 60-70. I would’ve even settled for half. That’s pathetic and really shouldn’t be happening to someone who’s been shopping there for years. I hate writing this but I haven’t been treated this poorly in a very long time. I hope they can fix this issue and be more clear on their pricing because the reality is you’re not getting what you’re cards are worth and you won’t get what they will tell you they’re worth. Wish it could’ve went different. Also just noticing that my cards aren’t even in a different order from when they started XD DONT SHOP HERE Show less
Ben S
Called them to see if they had riftbound packs in. They said yes but they didn't mention they were selling them for skalper prices. I understand the $5 per pack is the MSRP is technically a suggestion from the makers but when you sell product for the same price as skalpers. You become a skalper..... Read more
Called them to see if they had riftbound packs in. They said yes but they didn't mention they were selling them for skalper prices. I understand the $5 per pack is the MSRP is technically a suggestion from the makers but when you sell product for the same price as skalpers. You become a skalper... Show less
Ben S
Called them to see if they had riftbound packs in. They said yes but they didn't mention they were selling them for skalper prices. I understand the $5 per pack is the MSRP is technically a suggestion from the makers but when you sell product for the same price as skalpers. You become a skalper..... Read more
Called them to see if they had riftbound packs in. They said yes but they didn't mention they were selling them for skalper prices. I understand the $5 per pack is the MSRP is technically a suggestion from the makers but when you sell product for the same price as skalpers. You become a skalper... Show less
Jonah James
Game Time has been my go-to store since starting up collecting Pokémon cards a few months ago. I am a person with autism and a lot of anxiety, but they have always been welcoming and I have always felt safe. They've helped answer my silly questions about things, and today they helped resolve somethi... Read more
Game Time has been my go-to store since starting up collecting Pokémon cards a few months ago. I am a person with autism and a lot of anxiety, but they have always been welcoming and I have always felt safe. They've helped answer my silly questions about things, and today they helped resolve something I was very very anxious about. They were super kind and understanding. I wish I knew the specific names so I could shout them out, but please just know you are all appreciated! I really like digging through the Pokémon bulk that is in the center of the store. I have also purchased a binder there and some singles for decent/comparable prices. I have a lot to learn and am definitely not an expert, but Game Time is my favorite local shop and I always know I can go there when I want to find new cards! Show less
Jonah James
Game Time has been my go-to store since starting up collecting Pokémon cards a few months ago. I am a person with autism and a lot of anxiety, but they have always been welcoming and I have always felt safe. They've helped answer my silly questions about things, and today they helped resolve somethi... Read more
Game Time has been my go-to store since starting up collecting Pokémon cards a few months ago. I am a person with autism and a lot of anxiety, but they have always been welcoming and I have always felt safe. They've helped answer my silly questions about things, and today they helped resolve something I was very very anxious about. They were super kind and understanding. I wish I knew the specific names so I could shout them out, but please just know you are all appreciated! I really like digging through the Pokémon bulk that is in the center of the store. I have also purchased a binder there and some singles for decent/comparable prices. I have a lot to learn and am definitely not an expert, but Game Time is my favorite local shop and I always know I can go there when I want to find new cards! Show less
Opening Hours
Friday: 12 to 10 PM Saturday: 10 AM to 8 PM Sunday: Closed Monday: 12 to 8 PM Tuesday: 12 to 8 PM Wednesday: 12 to 8 PM Thursday: 12 to 8 PM